LONDON, 12 September 2006 – The dwindling pool of skilled officers in the marine industry could result in increasing claims and higher premiums in the long term, according to the leading insurance broker Aon. Marine operators need to combat the skills shortfall through more effective recruitment and retention plans to ensure future officers are fully equipped to handle technological advances and new trading patterns, thus preventing claims as a result of human error.
While the shipping industry continues to boom and the number of vessels is increasing year on year, employee numbers are keeping pace. Despite a surplus of ratings, there is an estimated shortage of around 10,000 officers or about 2% of the total workforce. With a predicted shortfall of some 27,000 officers, or just fewer than 6% of the total workforce, by the year 2015, the problem could escalate to the point where shipping companies will have to face real operational difficulties. Furthermore, while the global shipyard order book stands at 4,942 ships with a further 796 vessels under construction, it is clear the industry is facing a major challenge.
For the industry to address this issue successfully, it must combat the factors that are causing the skills shortage:
-
an ageing officer population with 50% over 40 years old;
-
the notion that seafaring is an unsafe line of work with the threat of piracy and officer kidnapping;
-
the shift of labour from North America, Europe, Japan and other OECD countries to east Europe and Asia means that the lack of international experience and cultural/ language skills are posing serious barriers to mariners wanting to take on global officer roles;
-
new legislation, such as the European Union’s ship source pollution directive which criminalises negligence, is acting as a deterrent to those thinking of joining the industry and causing some to leave;
-
as today’s vessels become more complex and technically advanced, the skills and knowledge required to manage them need to grow accordingly.
Steve Allum, chairman of Aon Global Marine, said: “Unless shipowners, managers and charterers take further action, the outlook for the maritime industry is not good. With diluted experience and training among crews, the possibility of human error is significantly higher and will inevitably lead to increased incidents and accidents. Technology alone cannot be expected to replace the loss of skilled crew in, for example, navigating congested shipping lanes. The inevitable consequence would be a higher cost of risk. Crew employment, training and retention policies may well become part of the key parameters which underwriters use to establish insurance premium for marine operators.”
Water for Fish, a leading people and organisation consultancy and an Aon company, identifies how shipping companies can address skill shortages:
-
recruit mariners or identify their own ratings with the potential to develop;
-
introduce a more rigorous selection process for fast track scheme candidates;
-
look to new labour centres such as east Europe, India and China for skilled officers;
-
liaise with international maritime training institutions to attract graduates;
-
conduct stimulating recruitment campaigns – focusing on the positives such as the International Labour Organisation’s strict new rules on working hours - to attract people outside the industry who may initially lack technical knowledge but have the appropriate management skills;
-
establish more comprehensive ongoing and recorded training and development to underpin professionalism of industry;
-
work towards a comprehensive succession planning process;
-
take action to retain staff looking at pay, work/life balance, career pathing etc.
Nicola Mindell, director of Water for Fish, comments: “As external factors such as government legislation are beyond the control of shipping companies, it means that they need to take responsibility for what they can control - the quality of their own employees. Mariners must ensure they have a comprehensive and sufficiently broad retention and recruitment strategy to keep and bring in experienced officers but also focus on those who have the potential to develop.”
Notes to editor: