Managing Reputational Risks in Global Supply Chains

Managing Reputational Risks in Global Supply Chains
Trade

09 of 12

This insight is part 09 of 12 in this Collection.

January 12, 2024 9 mins

Managing Reputational Risks in Global Supply Chains

Managing Reputational Risks in Global Supply Chains Hero Banner

Supply chain disruptions can have serious reputational repercussions, causing plummeting shareholder value and diminished stakeholder trust. The potential fallout underscores the need for management strategies that collectively address these risks.

Key Takeaways
  1. Supply chain events that undermine reputation can erode stakeholder confidence and impact long-term profitability.
  2. Amid growing public and regulatory scrutiny, organizations face accountability for ESG-related reputational risks within their supply chains.
  3. Leaders should implement a mitigation roadmap to manage existing reputational risk in supply chains and stay ahead of evolving regulations.

The intersection of supply chain and reputational risks has created a perfect storm that poses a potential threat to both an organization’s profitability and brand equity.

Understanding and managing risks within supply chains is already a complex exercise. Supply chain management requires driving efficiency and margin through sourcing strategies, while facing various challenges including natural disasters, cyber threats and geopolitical instability.

At the same time, risk management must also contend with environmental, social and governance (ESG)-related exposures within the global supply chain. And these can have longer-term reputational impact, which may lead to both loss of stakeholder confidence and shareholder value.

ESG threats can cause downstream effects on supply chains, including product recalls, launch delays and unexpected price hikes, eroding customer confidence and investor trust. Further, these threats are quite common, with 43 percent of organizations experiencing financial loss in the past 12 months due to supply chain risks.

Managing Reputational Risks in Global Supply Chains Diagram

In this environment, risk managers are working to better understand how to manage supply chain risk to avoid reputational exposures. “Supply chain activities, from raw material acquisition to component availability, shortages and product delivery, are all very public,” says Ladd Muzzy, Global Reputation Risk Practice Leader at Aon. “Stakeholders are seeking and expecting prompt answers of how the organization will respond to ensure operational resiliency.”

Mapping ESG-Driven Reputational Risks in Supply Chains

ESG reputational risks frequently originate in supply chains. These risks are often a result of highly visible exposures, such as environmental damage and excessive carbon emissions or human rights abuses. Reputation risks can also be brought on by strategic decisions that include supply chain as part of a larger business model. Understanding risk holistically ensures that all activities are part of the risk evaluation process.

Companies also face increasing legislative demands in an evolving regulatory landscape. These create expectations for organizations to conduct due diligence on their supply chains and ESG risks, including customer data, greenhouse gas emissions, health and safety — the list goes on. Enterprises that fall short may face significant fines, loss of business and investigation expenses, while also suffering damage to their reputations.

8th

Brand and reputation risk is the eighth biggest risk that global enterprises face today and has been a top-of-mind risk for leadership since 2007.

Source: Aon’s Global Risk Management Survey 2023

Reputational Impact of Modern Supply Chain Risk on Businesses

Reputation risks do not always cause direct interruption in supply chains, but consequences may be significant.

  • Inadequate cyber governance

    A company with inadequate cybersecurity has a risk of experiencing a data breach and may face regulatory fines from bodies like the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), impacting their reputation in the process.1

  • Lack of awareness about suppliers’ labor conditions

    A company that is unaware of its suppliers’ labor conditions could potentially risk using child labor in its supply chains. This could not only lead to fines from regulations, such as the Germany Supply Chain Act,2 but also lower reputational standing with stakeholders.

  • Lack of awareness about raw materials source

    A company that does now know the source of the rubber materials in its supply chain could potentially have a higher risk of supporting illegal activities. This could include deforestation that destroys rainforests,3 which could in turn damage its reputation.

  • Material supply risk leading to unfulfillment of net-zero commitment

    A company that has made a commitment to be net-zero by 2030, but is unable to deliver on this promise in its supply chain due to materials supply risk could not only face a decline in employee sentiment within the organization, but also draw the ire of advocacy groups.

  • Procurement of raw materials from countries with ongoing geopolitical concerns

    A company that sources chips in its automotive supply chain could experience continued impact from the ongoing shortage and be unable to deliver final products to customers,resulting in loss of stakeholder trust.

6th

Supply chain failures rank sixth in the top 10 list of risks facing organizations.

Source: Aon’s Global Risk Management Survey 2023

Quote icon

Sourcing decisions of any material in the supply chain that are construed to damage the environment, labor or public health can hurt a company’s brand. When you don’t have visibility of those risks beyond direct suppliers, your reputation is exposed.

LeAnn Timble
Director of Emerging Property Risk Control, North America

Case Study: The Impact of Supply Chain Disruptions on Shareholder Value

In March 2000, a fire broke out at a plant located within the United States. The fire was controlled quickly, but smoke and water damage destroyed the stock and as a result, production for a key component to be delivered to two global clients stalled. Disruption to production was expected to last a week, but continued for months.

The incident impacted two of the supplier’s clients who are competitors and whose divergent responses illustrate the impact of understanding the risks related to raw material sources. One company (Company A) had alternative supplies in place quickly and was able to pivot and restore capacity. On the other hand, their competitor (Company B) did not have the same level of supply chain resiliency and suffered substantial reputational damage, losing considerable market share as a result.5

Company B’s Dependency on a Single Source of Supply Leads to Loss of Market Share

Company B’s Dependency on a Single Source of Supply Leads to Loss of Market Share Chart
  • Response
    • The company accepts early assurances and awaits further news
    • Its simplified supply chain is unable to respond when needed
    • It does not disclose until part of its regular reporting cycle
    • The company quits the mobile phone business
  • Value Impact Post-Event
    • $63 billion in shareholder value lost over post-event year, representing a 38 percent drop
  • Lessons Learned
    • Be proactive to determine facts
    • Disclose early to key stakeholders
    • Understand the consequences

Competitor Company A With Diversified Supply Chain Adds Shareholder Value

Competitor Company A With Diversified Supply Chain Adds Shareholder Value Chart
  • Response
    • The company reacts quickly, dispatching engineers to inspect the damage
    • It secures spare capacity and orders key supplies from alternative suppliers
    • It demonstrates awareness and discloses details early
    • The company cements its position as a market leader in Europe
  • Value Impact Post-Event
    • $58 billion in shareholder value added over post-event year, representing a 25 percent increase
  • Lessons Learned
    • Build resilience into the supply chain
    • Take the initiative to assess damage
    • Be transparent with stakeholders
    • Recognize the problem

A Roadmap to Managing Reputational Risk in Supply Chains

In the face of intensifying interconnectivity between risks and growing stakeholder demand for accountability, modern businesses cannot afford to ignore reputation risks in their supply chain. While 74 percent of respondents in Aon’s Global Risk Management Survey stated their organization was prepared for supply chain risk, only 51 percent felt prepared to respond to reputation risk.

To manage reputational challenges existing within supply chains, business leaders may consider these risks in tandem via an enterprise-wide mitigation exercise that brings together different functions, such as procurement, corporate affairs, risk, IT and legal.

A roadmap could include:

  1. Mapping the supply chain to understand where the risk is and to pinpoint critical suppliers, examining supply chain policies and conducting due diligence on supply chain partners
  2. Evaluating the competences and capabilities that an organization has in place prior to an event and identifying where improvements can be made to manage supply chain reputation exposures
  3. Implementing reputation analytics and risk monitoring to evaluate the wider reputational impact of a supply chain event
  4. Reviewing existing risk financing approaches and exploring risk transfer options such as insurance or captive solutions
  5. Assessing adequacy of insurance cover by understanding the interconnectedness of reputation risk with other exposures and related peril policies
  6. Deriving capital benefits through risk retention options
Quote icon

Insurance is a useful instrument for introducing enhanced liquidity to help clean up damage from a reputation event. But it's ultimately how a company prepares for the event that will make a difference in whether confidence in their firm returns.

Richard Waterer
Global Risk Consulting Leader, Aon

Staying Ahead of the Risk

By preparing for and managing reputation risks within supply chains, organizations will be able to make better business decisions, improve financial and resource allocation, and in turn, reap capital benefits. Understanding the reputation implications within supply chains can lead to beneficial tactical decisions that reduce potential exposures, such as supplier concentration, non-compliance and the unavailability of products or their inputs.

Taking steps now to understand, manage and mitigate the reputation risks inherent in supply chains can ensure that organizations are proactive in addressing potential unwanted financial and non-financial exposures.

Discover how reputation risk analytics can protect shareholder value and preserve stakeholder trust.

1 Cost of a Data Breach Report 2023, IBM Security, July 2023, https://www.ibm.com/downloads/cas/E3G5JMBP.
The German Supply Chain Act: Overview and the practical challenges for companies, Norton Rose Fulbright, February 2023, https://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/en/knowledge/publications/ff7c1d04/the-german-supply-chain-act.
3 Opaque rubber supply chains are obscuring deforestation and biodiversity risks, Zoological Society of London, March 28, 2023, https://www.zsl.org/news-and-events/news/opaque-rubber-supply-chains-are-obscuring-deforestation-and-biodiversity-risks.
4 The semiconductor shortage is – mostly – over for the auto industry, S&P Global Mobility, July 12, 2023, https://www.spglobal.com/mobility/en/research-analysis/the-semiconductor-shortage-is-mostly-over-for-the-auto-industry.html.
5 Data for the case study was provided by the Aon Centre for Innovation & Analytics.

Aon’s Thought Leaders
  • Vesa Hakanen
    Leader of AGRC EMEA Supply Chain Risk Solution
  • Martin McGovern
    Director for Aon’s Actuarial and Data Science Practice
  • Ladd Muzzy
    Global Head of Reputation Risk Management, Aon
  • LeAnn Timble
    Director of Emerging Property Risk Control, North America
  • Richard Waterer
    Global Risk Consulting Leader, Aon

General Disclaimer

The information contained herein and the statements expressed are of a general nature and are not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavor to provide accurate and timely information and use sources we consider reliable, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate as of the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. No one should act on such information without appropriate professional advice after a thorough examination of the particular situation.

Terms of Use

The contents herein may not be reproduced, reused, reprinted or redistributed without the expressed written consent of Aon, unless otherwise authorized by Aon. To use information contained herein, please write to our team.

More Like This

View All
  • Credit Insurance and The Future of Energy

    Article 7 mins

    Credit Insurance and The Future of Energy

    In a conversation with Trade Finance Global’s (TFG) Deputy Editor, Mahika Ravi Shankar, Madeleine Whiteley, Senior Client Manager at Aon, explored how credit insurance is helping energy clients navigate volatility, adapt to the transition to renewables, and manage the uncertainties of today’s market

  • As Health Spend Soars, Employers Should Beware of Hidden Cost Threats

    Article 9 mins

    As Health Spend Soars, Employers Should Beware of Hidden Cost Threats

    While cancer care and specialty medicines are familiar culprits behind rising U.S. healthcare costs, benefit leaders should also watch out for less obvious factors driving up expenses. Taking a holistic view requires being aware of these hidden threats as you work to manage costs.

  • Risk Factors and Conditions Driving the Global Medical Trend Rate

    Article 8 mins

    Risk Factors and Conditions Driving the Global Medical Trend Rate

    The global medical trend rate is projected to dip below double digits for the first time in three years to 9.8%. It may be a hopeful sign that cost increases have plateaued, but cost increases are still elevated. We explain the risks and conditions behind the increase so employers can prepare.

  • 6 Insights to Build Risk Resilience in a Volatile Retail Market

    Article 9 mins

    6 Insights to Build Risk Resilience in a Volatile Retail Market

    Retailers in North America are navigating intense competition, shifting consumer demands and rising costs. Add to that a wave of evolving risks — from cyber to litigation — and the pressure mounts. These six insights can help retailers rethink their risk strategy.

  • Cyber Risk Is the Weak Link in Data Center Construction

    Article 8 mins

    Cyber Risk is the Weak Link in Data Center Construction

    Data center construction is booming — but cyber risk management hasn’t kept pace. As digital infrastructure becomes ever more critical, fit-for-purpose insurance solutions are essential to protect projects from costly cyber events that derail timelines and budgets.

  • Global Insurance Market Overview

    Article 23 mins

    Q3 2025: Global Insurance Market Overview

    Buyer-friendly conditions persisted in Q3, with ample capacity and intense competition driving continued price reductions and broader coverage for preferred risks, especially in property, cyber, and directors and officers.

  • Managing the Top 3 Risks in Infrastructure Projects: What You Need to Know

    Article 10 mins

    Resilient Infrastructure: 3 Risks to Watch

    Cost inflation, project complexity and tight schedules aren’t the only pressures facing infrastructure stakeholders. Emerging risks — from design and contract misalignment to tech-driven vulnerabilities — demand proactive risk management across the entire project lifecycle.

  • business-team-discussion-960645142

    Article 5 mins

    Rethinking Talent Strategy as H1B Visa Costs Rise

    As H1B visa costs surge, organizations face complex decisions in talent strategy and global workforce planning. This article explores how employers, talent, and industry must adapt holistically to remain resilient and competitive amid sweeping immigration and market changes.

  • Country-Level Findings

    Article 41 mins

    Country-Level Findings

    Explore how risk perceptions vary across countries with insights from Aon’s 2025 Global Risk Management Survey.

  • Top 10 Global Risks

    Article 1 mins

    Regional Results

    Aon’s 2025 Global Risk Management Survey explores how organizations across four regions are responding to top risks—revealing both the challenges they face and the opportunities to build resilience in a fast-changing world.

  • Logistics

    Article 11 mins

    High Stakes in High Tech: Securing the Technology Supply Chain

    As in-demand, high-value technology cargo travels through complex supply chains, any disruption can trigger costly delays and reputational damage. Leaders can manage volatility with a future-ready risk management approach backed by innovative insurance solutions and data-driven logistics.

  • 2026 Salary Increase Planning Tips

    Article 5 mins

    2026 Salary Increase Planning Tips

    Global voluntary turnover remains low, shaping cautious 2026 salary budgets and prompting a renewed focus on employee development to sustain engagement. Employers are balancing cost control with strategic investments in skills, paying high performers, pay equity and total rewards.

  • GRMS Industry Insights Hero Banner

    Article 1 mins

    Industry Insights

    Business risks impact industries in different ways. Aon’s 2025 Global Risk Management Survey reveals how organizations across nine sectors are responding to today’s most pressing threats—from geopolitical volatility and cyber risk to supply chain disruption and talent shortages.

  • Cyber and E&O: Pricing Holds, but Market Momentum is Shifting

    Article 10 mins

    Cyber and E&O: Pricing Holds, but Market Momentum is Shifting

    The global cyber and tech errors and omissions market continues to favor buyers — for now. As AI-driven threats, privacy litigation and supply chain exposures intensify, forward-thinking organizations are using this window to build resilience.

  • Business Interruption: Managing Risk in an Interconnected World

    Article 7 mins

    Business Interruption: Managing Risk in an Interconnected World

    Business interruption is the second-highest global risk in 2025 — but is expected to fall to seventh place by 2028. As interconnected threats multiply, from cyber attacks to climate events, organizations must diversify supply chains, embed geopolitical insight and regularly update continuity plans.

  • Cash Flow and Liquidity Hero Image

    Article 6 mins

    Cash Flow and Liquidity Risk: A Rising Challenge

    Cash flow and liquidity risk re-enters the top ten global risks in 2025 — and is expected to remain in tenth place by 2028. Amid an uncertain macroeconomic outlook, organizations must strengthen forecasting and unlock working capital to build financial resilience.

  • Commodity Price Risk and Material Scarcity: An Escalating and Complex Risk

    Article 7 mins

    Commodity Price Risk and Material Scarcity: An Escalating and Complex Risk

    Commodity price risk ranks sixth globally in 2025 — and is forecast to climb to fourth place by 2028. With supply chains strained by geopolitical tensions and climate disruption, organizations should consider hedging strategies, diversifying sourcing and exploring innovative risk transfer solutions.

  • Cyber Attack or Data Breach Hero Image

    Article 6 mins

    Cyber Risk: Turning Uncertainty into Opportunity

    Cyber risk tops the global risk agenda in 2025 — and is forecast to retain the number one position through to 2028. As digital threats evolve, organizations should strengthen resilience, quantify exposure and adapt their risk strategy.

  • Damage to Reputation or Brand Hero Image

    Article 5 mins

    Damage to Reputation or Brand: A Critical Risk

    Damage to reputation or brand ranks eighth globally in 2025 — but is expected to fall to nineteenth by 2028. In an era of cyber threats, ESG scrutiny and social media amplification, organizations should quantify reputational risk and embed preventive measures into enterprise strategy.

  • Geopolitical Volatility Hero Image

    Article 6 mins

    Geopolitical Volatility: Preparing for the Unpredictable

    Geopolitical volatility ranks ninth globally in 2025 — and is forecast to rise to fifth by 2028. With conflict, trade disruption and political instability on the rise, organizations must monitor global developments, regularly assess operational exposure and conduct scenario planning.

  • Increasing Competition Is Intensifying Risk for Organizations

    Article 5 mins

    Increasing Competition Is Intensifying Risk for Organizations

    Increasing competition ranks as the fifth biggest global risk in 2025 — and is projected to climb to number three by 2028. As technological disruption, talent scarcity and geopolitical shifts intensify market pressure, organizations must embrace agility, and rethink competitive strategy.

  • Navigating Regulatory and Legislative Change

    Article 8 mins

    Navigating Regulatory and Legislative Change

    Regulatory change ranks as the fourth biggest global risk in 2025 — and is expected to fall to sixth place by 2028. As policy shifts accelerate across sustainability, technology, trade and the workforce, organizations must adopt agile compliance strategies and unlock proactive risk management.

  • Supply Chain or Distribution Failure: Navigating the New Normal

    Article 9 mins

    Supply Chain or Distribution Failure: Navigating the New Normal

    Supply chain failure ranks seventh globally in 2025 — and is projected to fall to twelfth place by 2028. As weather-related disruption, geopolitical tension and cyber threats converge, organizations must balance efficiency with resilience and diversify sourcing.

  • Top 10 Global Risks

    Article 1 mins

    Top 10 Global Risks

    As risks increasingly overlap and evolve, managing them demands more than reactive strategies. This chapter explores the top-ranked risks from the survey and highlights how organizations that take a proactive, integrated approach can turn complexity into opportunity.

  • Why Economic Slowdown is an Ongoing Risk for Organizations

    Article 6 mins

    Why Economic Slowdown is an Ongoing Risk for Organizations

    Economic slowdown ranks as the number three global risk in 2025 — and is projected to rise to number two by 2028. Amid trade tensions, inflation and geopolitical instability, organizations must strengthen liquidity, enhance workforce agility and rethink capital strategies to stay resilient.

  • Client Trends 2025

    Article 11 mins

    In Conversation with Iberdrola: Navigating Megatrends

    Spanish energy multinational, Iberdrola – a leader in grids, storage and clean energy – talks with Aon about its efforts to adapt and respond to climate impacts through its shift towards renewables and building a workforce for the future.

  • Q2 2025 UK Insurance Market Outlook

    Article 13 mins

    Q2 2025 UK Insurance Market Outlook

    Despite geopolitical instability and an uncertain economic outlook, insurer competition in the UK remains strong. This ongoing competition has shaped buyer-friendly conditions for most insurance lines, which began in late 2024 and have continued throughout the first and second quarters of 2025.

  • 5 Bold Predictions for the Future of Total Rewards

    Article 6 mins

    5 Bold Predictions for the Future of Total Rewards

    Total rewards professionals must adapt quickly to changes in the workforce. Whether it's personalization of benefits powered by AI or a whole new language around total rewards, the near future may look very different than the status quo.

  • 5 Data-Driven Ways HR Can Optimize Costs

    Article 17 mins

    5 Data-Driven Ways HR Can Optimize Costs

    Data and analytics can unlock value for HR professionals in a variety of ways. From a unified global benefits perspective to personalizing total rewards, gathering and analyzing the right types of data help companies optimize what can be their biggest expense.

  • SPACs Return: Why D&O Risk Management Must Step Up

    Article 8 mins

    SPACs Return: Why D&O Risk Management Must Step Up

    SPACs are staging a comeback, but the risks that surrounded them in prior cycles remain. The challenge is to lead with proactive, strategic risk transfer that keeps stakeholders and balance sheets protected in a fast-evolving landscape.

  • Sustainable Fuel in Transit: Overcoming Roadblocks to Adoption

    Article 10 mins

    Sustainable Fuel in Transit: Overcoming Roadblocks to Adoption

    The transportation industry is one of the highest emitters of greenhouse gases — and among the most primed for change — but the journey to decarbonize remains complex. Stakeholder collaboration will be critical in making sustainable fuel mainstream in aviation and marine.