Price volatility is also a challenge for energy transition: the expectation was that the shift towards renewable energy sources, (such as wind and solar which introduces intermittency and variability in supply) could lead to price fluctuations - but how extreme would they be? The present environment has presented a different concern, rather than “how to manage exposures”, the question is “how to make a profit”? Energy traders and offtakers are reluctant to fix pricing when the future is uncertain: geopolitical events and changes in consumer demand have significant influence on energy prices. Moreover, localised concerns such as the previous uncertainty around UK zonal pricing, Spain extraordinarily experiencing negative pricing, and subsidies in Italy are having an impact on competition. Battery storage could become integral to stabilising solar and wind power fluctuations, however, has yet to solve the problems at hand.
Long-Term Agreements: Navigating Extended Risks
Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) are fundamental to the financing and development of renewable energy projects. These long-term contracts, typically spanning 10 to 25 years, are the future revenue streams which enable developers to secure financing to invest in new capacity. Whilst developers are exposed to the offtaker’s payment obligations, the offtakers themselves are exposed to significant risk on the producing asset over a long period of time for which there is very little mitigation. Where offtakers agree to long term contracts, any impact on supply could affect onward sale of the energy and crucially eat into increasingly thinning margins. Seeking new supply should the renewable asset fail is costly both in terms of returns and reputation. Changes in market conditions, regulatory shifts, or the financial health of a counterparty on a longer-term (and therefore less predictable) time-horizon can jeopardize the fulfilment of these long-term commitments.
It has historically been a challenge for credit insurers to provide cover on these counterparties with limited balance sheets and no track history, particularly for long term cover. However, we have seen Export Credit Agencies (ECA’s) providing support for green projects and private insurers could be encouraged to collaborate with the ECA’s as they build up experience and therefore comfort to widen their appetite.
Tariffs on LNG: Adapting to Geopolitical Complexities
Liquefied natural gas (LNG) plays a significant role in the global energy mix, providing a flexible and an arguably cleaner alternative to traditional fossil fuels. International trade in LNG, however, is subject to a complex web of tariffs, trade policies, and geopolitical considerations. The EU’s tilt away from Russian natural gas, by focusing on securing LNG particularly through longer-term contracts, has been one such major shift. These factors can significantly impact the price competitiveness of LNG and create credit risks for both buyers and sellers.
With the US imposing tariffs in an unpredictable manner, Europe's first cold winter since the Ukrainian conflict broke out (with sources citing that Europe’s LNG stores are at c. 33% of the 90% required by the end of the summer) and the unknown of Asian demand over the summer, where will prices go? And where gas prices go, electricity is soon to follow.